General Liability
-
March 10, 2025
Insurer May Be Liable For Coverage Of School Abuse Suits
A Washington federal judge said an insurer may still be liable for covering underlying claims of physical and sexual abuse against staff at a boarding school for troubled youth on the state's Cypress Island, because one policy year unlike others was missing an endorsement requiring connection to a particular location.
-
March 10, 2025
4th Circ. Reverses $10M Coverage Cap For Aluminum Co.
The Fourth Circuit on Monday reversed a lower court's ruling capping an aluminum supplier's total recovery for losses related to a fire at $10 million, saying a molten material endorsement in the company's all-risk policies is ambiguous.
-
March 10, 2025
Freight Co. Says Cellphone Dealer Ignoring Discovery Bids
A freight coordination company said it has no choice but to ask a North Carolina federal court to sanction a cellphone dealer who sued it after a truckload of devices was stolen, claiming that it hasn't received adequate discovery responses.
-
March 07, 2025
$48M Progressive Deal With NY Drivers Gets Finalized
A New York federal court on Friday officially signed off on a $48 million class action settlement various Progressive Insurance units reached with New York drivers to resolve their claims that Progressive underpaid their claims for totaled vehicles.
-
March 07, 2025
Gas Station Asks 11th Circ. To Revive Pollution Coverage Suit
A Florida gas station owner asked the Eleventh Circuit on Friday to revive its lawsuit trying to get Nautilus Insurance Co. to cover the costs to clean up contamination caused by a leaking underground fuel tank, telling the appeals court the company did not learn of the leak until after the policy went into effect.
-
March 07, 2025
Cosmetics Co. Sues Insurer Over Calif. Water Pollution Claims
A cosmetics company facing water pollution claims told a California federal court its insurer denied coverage in bad faith, saying though the insurer agreed to defend a lawsuit from the California attorney general, the insurer still wrongly refused to reimburse costs from two prior, related suits that were ultimately rescinded.
-
March 07, 2025
False Policy Info Tanks Property Owner's Coverage Suit
A New York federal judge ruled that an insurer doesn't have to cover a property owner and manager embroiled in a dispute with Vrbo tenants who fell through the balcony of a South Carolina condo, because the owner lied to the carrier and said it didn't offer short-term rentals.
-
March 06, 2025
Federal Insurance Monitor In Crosshairs Amid Executive Cuts
Republicans on the state and federal level are targeting the U.S. Department of the Treasury's insurance monitor amid President Donald Trump's effort to drastically reduce the size of the federal workforce across many departments, putting the future of the monitor and its work in doubt.
-
March 06, 2025
Fla. Report Draws Serious Accusations Of Insurer Misconduct
A Florida analysis showing that carriers in the state were reporting millions in income losses while affiliated companies were earning billions is helping to reveal a long-standing pattern of insurer misconduct, according to consumer advocates.
-
March 06, 2025
Experts Stress FAIR Tweaks After NM Proposes Fire Insurance
The announcement of a study looking into the creation of a state-sponsored fire insurance program in New Mexico outlined steps the state is taking toward enhancing its insurance market while underscoring the need for changes to the state's Fair Access to Insurance Requirements Plan and mitigation practices, experts say.
-
March 06, 2025
Pricey Privacy Suits Prompt Insurers To Assess Coverage
The Sixth Circuit's ruling earlier this year that an electronic data exclusion in Home Depot's insurance policies barred coverage for a $50 million claim stemming from a 2014 data breach is the latest example of the potential cost of privacy litigation to policyholders — even those who believe they have ample coverage.
-
March 06, 2025
Cobalt Miner Gets OK For Debt-For-Equity Swap Ch. 11 Plan
A Texas bankruptcy judge Thursday approved the reorganization plan of Australia-based cobalt mining and refining group Jervois Mining Ltd., overruling a shareholder objection about the case's speed and U.S. ties.
-
March 06, 2025
Insurers Seek Toss Of Meta's Social Media MDL Coverage Suit
A group of insurers urged a California federal court to either toss or stay Meta's suit seeking to pause all coverage litigation regarding underlying claims that the company deliberately designed its platforms to be addictive to adolescents, saying the first-to-file rule applies to the carriers' Delaware state court suit.
-
March 06, 2025
Insurance Litigation Week In Review
Colorado's last-resort property insurer partnered with an artificial intelligence company, a Hawaii federal court admonished insurers for not complying with an arbitration order, a New York federal judge found reasonable contract interpretations on both sides of an insurance dispute and a Delaware judge sent a coverage battle to trial. Here, Law360 takes a look at this week's top insurance news.
-
March 06, 2025
Pigment Co. Not Covered For Asbestos Suits, Court Told
A Liberty Mutual unit doesn't owe coverage to a cosmetic pigment manufacturer in underlying suits alleging injury from exposure to asbestos-containing materials, it told a New York federal court, saying certain claims fall outside the scope of coverage because they're not based on the company's work.
-
March 05, 2025
Construction Co. Not Covered For $11M Verdict, Insurer Says
A construction company isn't entitled to coverage for an $11 million jury verdict against it in an underlying personal injury suit because the builder's policy excludes coverage for residential construction activities, an insurer told a Texas federal court.
-
March 05, 2025
Insurer Wants Out Of Covering Ill. Pot Potency Suit
Admiral Insurance Co. is asking an Illinois federal court to clear it of any duty to cover a Shelbyville dispensary in a suit alleging that it mislabeled its products to get around the state's limits on THC.
-
March 04, 2025
Insurer Says Claims Of Illegally Tracked Info Erase Coverage
An insurer for a fertility treatment provider told an Illinois federal court that an exclusion on the disclosure of personal information precludes commercial general liability coverage for a lawsuit accusing the provider of unlawfully installing tracking technologies to collect website users' private information.
-
March 04, 2025
Insurer, Reinsurer Denied Early Wins In Reimbursement Row
Both sides in an inter-insurer dispute over a reinsurer's share of a coverage settlement for environmental damage claims have adopted reasonable contractual interpretations, a New York federal court ruled, specifically finding ambiguities on whether the reinsurer must reimburse a plaintiff insurer with which it didn't directly do business.
-
March 04, 2025
Puerto Rico Cruise Port Says Insurer Must Cover Pier Damage
A San Juan cruise port operator said its Hartford insurer wrongfully denied coverage for damage to one of its piers after a cruise ship collided with the structure, telling a Puerto Rico federal court Tuesday that exclusions and clauses cited by the carrier were either inapplicable or misinterpreted.
-
March 03, 2025
Insurer Says It's Off The Hook In Construction Site Injury Suit
State National Insurance Co. urged a Washington federal court on Monday to find it has no duty to defend a construction firm from a negligence claim brought by a worker who was allegedly hit by a falling object while delivering materials to a Seattle job site in 2021.
-
March 03, 2025
Insurer Doesn't Owe Spine Surgery Suit Defense, Judge Says
An insurer has no duty to defend or indemnify an orthopedic treatment center or one of its surgeons in a suit over a botched spine surgery, a Georgia federal court ruled Monday, saying the policy bars coverage for claims reported to another insurer before its effective date.
-
March 03, 2025
Countertop Co. Demands Insurer Cover Over 100 Injury Suits
A distributor of countertops and flooring accused a Liberty Mutual unit in New York federal court of reversing its coverage position on nearly 130 underlying personal injury lawsuits in bad faith, arguing that each underlying plaintiff's alleged injuries should constitute separate occurrences.
-
February 28, 2025
Insurer Settles $6.7M Jet Engine Damage Dispute
An insurer for a subsidiary of aerospace and defense giant RTX Corp. told a Connecticut federal court it has settled its subrogation action against various contractors over more than $6.7 million in coverage the insurer said it paid for a jet engine damaged in a truck crash.
-
February 28, 2025
Insurer Gets Partial Early Win In Oil Pollution Coverage Suit
Because of a late notice, an insurer shouldn't have to defend an oil and gas company against litigation claiming it damaged neighboring land after it discharged wastewater, a U.S. magistrate judge recommended to a Texas federal court Friday, but indemnification might still be on table.
Expert Analysis
-
Rethinking Litigation Risk And What It Really Means To Win
Attorneys have a tendency to overestimate litigation risk before summary judgment and underestimate risk after it, but an eight-stage litigation framework can clarify risk at different points and help litigators reassess what true success looks like in any particular case, says Joshua Libling at Arcadia Finance.
-
A Federal Insurance Mandate For Private Aviation Is Overdue
A recent private plane crash in California that killed two people and injured 19 others spotlights the dangers of such occurrences — and serves as a reminder that because there is no federal requirement for general aviation pilots to carry insurance, the victims of these accidents are often unable to obtain fair compensation, says Timothy Loranger at Wisner Baum.
-
6 Predictions For Cyber Risk And Insurance In 2025
This year is likely to bring with it some thorny and expensive cyber challenges, including increased ransomware activity, more data breach class actions and continued efforts to define business interruption loss calculations, say attorneys at Wiley.
-
Defense Strategies For Addressing Conspiracy-Minded Jurors
As conspiracy theories continue to proliferate and gain traction in the U.S., defense attorneys will need to consider ways to keep conspiracy-minded jurors from sitting on the jury, and to persuade them when this isn’t possible, say consultants at IMS Legal Strategies.
-
Surprise NC COVID Ruling Revises Reasonable Expectations
The North Carolina Supreme Court's recent finding in favor of policyholders in a suit for business interruption coverage due to COVID-19 shutdown orders runs contrary to most other state and federal courts' holdings on the issue, and may revitalize the reasonable expectations doctrine in the state, say attorneys at Goldberg Segalla.
-
How Trial Attys Can Wield Amended Federal Evidence Rules
Trial lawyers should assess recent amendments to four Federal Rules of Evidence and a newly enacted rule on illustrative aids to determine how to best use the rules to enhance pretrial discovery and trial strategy, says Stewart Edelstein, former litigation chair at Cohen & Wolf.
-
Mich. Ruling Offers View On 'Occurrence' Coverage Definition
As demonstrated by a Michigan state court in its recent decision finding per-wound insurance coverage for a school shooting, the amount of coverage available under occurrence-based policies often depends on how courts interpret "occurrence," say attorneys at Hunton.
-
Identifying Deepfakes During Evidence Collection, Discovery
Excerpt from Practical Guidance
Attorneys must familiarize themselves with the tools used to create and detect deepfakes — media manipulated by artificial intelligence to convincingly mimic real people and events — as well as best practices for keeping this fabricated evidence out of court, says Bijan Ghom at Saxton & Stump.
-
1 Year After Rule 702 Changes, Courts Have Made Progress
In the year since amendments to the Federal Rules of Evidence went into effect, many federal judges have applied the new expert witness standard correctly, excluding unreliable testimony from their courts — but now state courts need to update their own rules accordingly, says Lee Mickus at Evans Fears.
-
An Underutilized Tool To Dismiss Meritless Claims In Texas
In Texas, special appearances provide a useful but often overlooked tool for out-of-state defendants to escape meritless claims early in litigation, thus limiting discovery and creating a pathway for immediate appellate review, say attorneys at Winston & Strawn.
-
How Texas Bill Would Transform Noneconomic Damages
Large noneconomic damage awards in personal injury cases have grown exponentially in Texas in recent years, but newly introduced legislation would cap such damages, likely requiring both the plaintiff and defense bars to recalibrate their litigation strategies, say attorneys at Norton Rose.
-
4 Holiday Movies Full Of Cheer And Subrogation Scenarios
While holiday movies are known for spreading cheer and inspiring nostalgia, for insurance professionals they may also offer an unlikely, yet fascinating, look at subrogation recovery potential, says Dana Meyers at Cozen O'Connor.
-
California's New AV Law May Steer Policy Nationwide
California's new law establishing various requirements for autonomous vehicles is something other states should pay close attention to — especially because the Golden State's policies may become a de facto mandate for manufacturers due to its market size, says Vineet Dubey at Custodio Dubey.